Formulation development of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies using high-throughput fluorescence and static light scattering techniques: role of conformational and colloidal stability.
Goldberg Deborah S,Bishop Steven M,Shah Ambarish U,Sathish Hasige A
Journal of pharmaceutical sciences
In this work, we describe the application of two different high-throughput screening (HTS) techniques that can be used to determine protein stability during early formulation development. Differential scanning fluorescence (DSF) and differential static light scattering (DSLS) are used to determine the conformational and colloidal stability of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) during thermal denaturation in a high-throughput fashion. DSF utilizes SYPRO Orange, a polarity-sensitive extrinsic fluorescent probe, to monitor protein unfolding. We found that melting temperatures determined by DSF have a linear correlation with melting temperatures of the first domain unfolding determined by differential scanning calorimetry, establishing DSF as a reliable method for measuring thermal stability. The DSLS method employs static light scattering to evaluate protein stability during thermal denaturation in a 384-well format. Overall comparison between mAb aggregation under typical accelerated stress conditions (40°C) and the thermal stability obtained by DSF and DSLS is also presented. Both of these HTS methods are cost effective with high-throughput capability and can be implemented in any laboratory. Combined with other emerging HTS techniques, DSF and DSLS could be powerful tools for mAb formulation optimization.
10.1002/jps.22371
Differential scanning calorimetry and fluorimetry measurements of monoclonal antibodies and reference proteins: Effect of scanning rate and dye selection.
Lang Brian E,Cole Kenneth D
Biotechnology progress
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) were used to measure the transition temperatures of four proteins: RNase A, invertase, rituximab, and the NISTmAb (NIST Reference Material, RM 8671). The proteins were combined with several different fluorescent dyes for the DSF measurements. This study compares the results of DSC and DSF measurements of transition temperatures with different types of proteins, dye combinations, and thermal scan rates. As protein unfolding is often influenced by kinetic effects, we measured the transition temperatures of the proteins using DSC over a range of temperature scan rates and compared them to the data obtained from DSF over comparable temperature scan rates. The results when the proteins were combined with Sypro Orange and bis-ANS for the DSF measurements had the best correlations with the transition temperatures determined by calorimetry. The scan rate was found to be an important variable when comparing results between DSC and DSF. The van't Hoff enthalpy changes for the transitions were calculated from the DSC data by using a non-two-state model and from the DSF values using a two-state model. The calculated van't Hoff enthalpy changes did not show a good correlation between the two methods. © 2017 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 33:677-686, 2017.
10.1002/btpr.2464
Probing Thermal Stability of Proteins with Temperature Scanning Viscometer.
Jiang Bowen,Jain Amita,Lu Yuwei,Hoag Stephen W
Molecular pharmaceutics
Thermal stability is essential for the understanding of protein stability and is a critical quality attribute of therapeutic biologics, including enzymes, fusion proteins, monoclonal antibodies, etc. The commonly used analytical methods, such as differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF), and circular dichroism (CD), have their limitations in measuring protein thermal stability. Through this work, we described a novel method to probe the thermal stability of proteins in various formulations using a temperature scanning viscometer. The viscosity of the material was plotted against the temperature, and the peak in the first derivative of the viscosity versus temperature was shown to be related to the protein melting temperature. The measured melting temperature of bovine serum albumin (BSA) at a concentration of 1 mg/mL in phosphate buffer was 63 °C, which was close to the value of 64 °C obtained by DSC. The unfolding of BSA was confirmed using orthogonal techniques of second derivative ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering (DLS). This method was also able to reveal the microenvironment changes of proteins, including formulation effects. Other multiple domains proteins including lysozyme and IgG were also tested using this method and showed comparable melting temperatures with DSC. This work showed the feasibility of using a temperature scanning viscometer to measure the thermal stability of proteins in diverse formulation matrices with wider protein concentration ranges.
10.1021/acs.molpharmaceut.9b00598
Effects of subclass change on the structural stability of chimeric, humanized, and human antibodies under thermal stress.
Protein science : a publication of the Protein Society
To address how changes in the subclass of antibody molecules affect their thermodynamic stability, we prepared three types of four monoclonal antibody molecules (chimeric, humanized, and human) and analyzed their structural stability under thermal stress by using size-exclusion chromatography, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), circular dichroism (CD), and differential scanning fluoroscopy (DSF) with SYPRO Orange as a dye probe. All four molecules showed the same trend in change of structural stability; the order of the total amount of aggregates was IgG1 < IgG2 < IgG4. We thus successfully cross-validated the effects of subclass change on the structural stability of antibodies under thermal stress by using four methods. The T(h) values obtained with DSF were well correlated with the onset temperatures obtained with DSC and CD, suggesting that structural perturbation of the CH2 region could be monitored by using DSF. Our results suggested that variable domains dominated changes in structural stability and that the physicochemical properties of the constant regions of IgG were not altered, regardless of the variable regions fused.
10.1002/pro.2340
DSF method optimization and its application in predicting protein thermal aggregation kinetics.
Shi Shuai,Semple Andrew,Cheung Jason,Shameem Mohammed
Journal of pharmaceutical sciences
Differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) has gained wide acceptance in the therapeutic protein development. However, the effects of dyes and surfactants that may affect structural transitions have not been studied thoroughly to date. We therefore first optimized the DSF method by studying surfactant-containing formulations and found that the presence of surfactants generally required medium-to-high protein concentrations and that high SYPRO® Orange concentration in a DSF experiment may lower protein thermal transitions. We also benchmarked DSF against differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and evaluated the capability of thermal parameters (from DSF/DSC) to predict real-time thermal aggregation kinetics monitored by size exclusion chromatography (SEC) and analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC) in different scenarios. For monoclonal antibody (MAb) fragment, both DSF and DSC were predictive of thermal aggregation rate. For MAb3, a good correlation was observed between DSF and DSC, none of which was, however, indicative of protein aggregation kinetics. In a surfactant ranging study, DSF did not agree with DSC and was not predictive of the aggregation kinetics of the MAb fragment. The concentration-dependent thermal behavior was also studied by DSF. Although higher concentration, in general, tends to lower protein transition temperature, case where it was independent of protein concentration was also presented.
10.1002/jps.23633
Thermostability detection and optimization of glycoengineered antibodies and antibody-drug conjugates based on differential scanning flouremitry analysis.
Qin Ken,Shi Wei,Zhao Lei,Li Mingjie,Tang Yubo,Faridoon ,Jiang Bofeng,Tang Feng,Huang Wei
Bioorganic chemistry
Thermostability of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs), as a critical property of biotherapeutics, is important for their physicochemical processes, pharmacodynamics, and pharmacokinetics. Fc glycosylation of mAbs plays a crucial role in antibody functions including thermostability, however, due to the lack of homogeneous glycosylation for comparison, the precise impact of glycoforms on thermostability of mAbs and ADCs remains challenging to elucidate. In this paper, we employed the technique of differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) to investigate the thermostability of Fc domains, glycoengineered mAbs, and ADCs, carrying well-defined N-glycan structures for comparison. The results revealed that high-mannose-type N-glycans dramatically reduce the T value of Fc, compared to complex-type N-glycans. We also found that core-fucose contributes to the thermostability of mAbs, and the unnatural modification on non-reducing end of biantennary N-glycan can compensate the reduced stability of afucosylated mAbs and maintain the advantage of enhanced antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC). DSF analysis of lysine-linked and glycosite-specific ADCs indicated that thermostability of glycan-linked ADCs is reduced, but it could be improved by using an optimized linkage. This work provides an in-depth analysis on thermostability of mAbs and ADCs with homogeneous glycoforms, and also proposes new strategies for optimizing glycoengineered mAbs and glycosite-specific ADCs using unnatural glycan and stabilized linkage.
10.1016/j.bioorg.2019.103391
Systematic analysis of Fc mutations designed to reduce binding to Fc-gamma receptors.
mAbs
Elimination of the binding of immunoglobulin Fc to Fc gamma receptors is highly desirable for the avoidance of unwanted inflammatory responses to therapeutic antibodies and fusion proteins. Many different approaches have been used in the clinic, but they have not been systematically compared. We have now produced a matched set of anti-CD20 antibodies with different Fc subclasses and variants and compared their activity for binding to C1q, Fc-gamma receptors and in cell-based assays. Most of the variants still have significant levels of activity in one or more of these assays and many of them have impaired temperature stability compared with the corresponding wild-type antibody.
10.1080/19420862.2024.2402701
Systematic analysis of Fc mutations designed to enhance binding to Fc-gamma receptors.
mAbs
A critical attribute of therapeutic antibodies is their ability to engage with humoral or cellular effector mechanisms, and this depends on the ability of the Fc region to bind to complement (C1q) or Fc receptors. Investigators have sought to optimize these effects by engineering the Fc region to bind to a greater or lesser extent to individual receptors. Different approaches have been used in the clinic, but they have not been systematically compared. We have now produced a matched set of anti-CD20 antibodies representing a range of variants and compared their activity in cell-based assays for complement-dependent cytotoxicity, antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity, and antibody-dependent phagocytosis using a range of individual Fc receptors. We have also compared the thermal stability of the variants by differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF). The results reveal a spectrum of activities which may be appropriate for different applications.
10.1080/19420862.2024.2406539
High-throughput screening of formulations to optimize the thermal stability of a therapeutic monoclonal antibody.
Niedziela-Majka Anita,Kan Elaine,Weissburg Perry,Mehra Upasana,Sellers Scott,Sakowicz Roman
Journal of biomolecular screening
Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are an important class of biotherapeutics. Successful development of a mAb depends not only on its biological activity but also on its physicochemical properties, such as homogeneity and stability. mAb stability is affected by its formulation. Among the many techniques used to study the stability of mAbs, differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) offers both excellent throughput and minimal material consumption. DSF measures the temperature of the protein unfolding transition (Tm) based on the change in fluorescence intensity of the environmentally sensitive dye SYPRO Orange. With DSF adapted to a 96-well plate format, we have shown that low-pH or high-salt concentrations decrease the thermal stability of mAb1, whereas some excipients, such as sucrose, polysorbate 80, and sodium phosphate, increase its stability. The basal fluorescence of SYPRO Orange was enhanced by the presence of detergents, limiting the use of this approach to diluted detergent solutions. Throughput of DSF can be increased further with the use of a 384-well plate. DSF thermograms are in good agreement with the melting profiles obtained by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The Tms determined by DSF and DSC were well correlated, with the former being on average lower by 3 °C.
10.1177/1087057114557781
High throughput thermostability screening of monoclonal antibody formulations.
He Feng,Hogan Sabine,Latypov Ramil F,Narhi Linda O,Razinkov Vladimir I
Journal of pharmaceutical sciences
Differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) was employed to increase the throughput of the thermostability screening of monoclonal antibody (mAb) formulations. The method consists of measuring the fluorescence intensity of a polarity sensitive probe at gradually increasing temperatures, and obtaining the transition temperature of exposure of the hydrophobic regions of proteins (T(h)). The change in fluorescence intensity was directly related to protein unfolding levels and temperatures. The results from thermostability measurements were compared with the data acquired using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and a good correlation between T(h) and the temperature of protein unfolding or melting (T(m)) was observed. The method was applied to screen four mAb molecules in 84 different buffers. The studies revealed a good correlation of T(h) values with the known effects of pH and excipients on protein stability in solution. Specifically, the elevated aggregation levels induced by salt, low pH, and high protein concentrations could be successfully predicted by this thermal stability screening. This method is efficient, with high throughput capability, and could be widely applied in the biopharmaceutical industry for formulation and process development, and characterization.
10.1002/jps.21955